4-Nov-2026

In-Frequently asked questions

What are HS2s legal obligations regarding restoration, and what else has been agreed ?

 HS2 is only obliged to construct and operate a railway –

1 Power to construct and maintain works for Phase One of High Speed 2
(1) The nominated undertaker may construct and maintain the works specified in
Schedule 1, being—
                (a) works for the construction of Phase One of High Speed 2, and
                (b) works consequent on, or incidental to, such works.

"The creation of a restoration or landscaping masterplan is not something that the project is required to
produce, nor required under the relevant legislation. The legislative framework that HS2 uses to deliver the scheme is Schedule 17 of the HS2 Act, this is the planning regime that HS2 Ltd and its contractors have a statutory requirement to follow.
" (Maddeylin Sutton, Head of Engagement, Mar 2025)

Beyond that, there are legally binding Undertakings and (frequently worthless) Assurances made during the passage of the bill. These were often negotiated in the corridors outside the Select Committee hearings, to persuade petitioners to withdraw their objections.

                The only references to the AoNB as a whole are the assurances made regarding the AoNB review group. This was largely driven by Cheryl Gillan – Chesham and Amersham MP at the time. Its functions are defined in Assurance 1008, 6 – to develop design principles, and comment on the ‘final design’ before its release. 1571 suggests the remit could be extended, to ‘integrate the scheme into the AoNB’, but this appears to be optional.

                That is the closest thing to an obligation on HS2 to give special consideration to the AoNB. However, HS2 like to appear ‘Green’ , with commitments to ‘No Net Loss’ of biodiversity, and the ‘Green Corridor’ (not sure if that is inside or outside the security fencing). This is underpinned by the ‘Environmental Minimum Requirements’ –

1.3.1 The Environmental Memorandum provides a framework for the nominated
undertaker and representatives of the National Environment Forum to work together
to ensure that the design and construction of Phase One of HS2 is carried out with
due regard for environmental considerations, including the historic environment.

1.1.3 The controls contained in the EMRs, along with powers contained in the High Speed Rail (London - West Midlands) Act (the Act) and the Undertakings given by the Secretary of State, will ensure that impacts which have been assessed in the Environmental Statement will not be exceeded

which the ‘nominated undertakers’ (contractors) are presumably contractually obliged to follow. This requires Local Environmental Management Plans (LEMPs) to be made for environmentally sensitive areas, one of which is the Chilterns. The Chilterns LEMP and other documents relating to landscape reconstruction are listed and linked from this page.

What's the problem ?

The published documents are full of fine aspirations, but short on details regarding what should be planted, and where, to fulfil them. Recently published 'Bringing into use' (BIU) applications (for example, Wendover Dean viaduct) contain detailed planting plans, but with little or no explanation as to why the various elements have been positioned as they are, or what functions they perform - other than 'screening'. The BIU applications are separate, standalone documents, and the various landscaping documents have insufficient detail to provide an overview.

Other uncertainties arise from the limited information provided -